A Clinician Question-and-Answer Guide Using the APA’s Official Framework
As artificial intelligence scribes become more common in behavioral health, clinicians often search for terms like “APA AI scribe evaluation,” “APA grading of AI scribes,” or “APA-approved AI scribe.”
The American Psychological Association does not approve, endorse, certify, or grade AI tools. Instead, the APA has published formal guidance outlining how psychologists and behavioral health clinicians should evaluate AI scribes before integrating them into practice.
This article follows that guidance closely. It presents the APA’s evaluation questions in a clear question-and-answer format and explains how PMHScribe approaches each domain so clinicians can make informed decisions. This content is educational and does not imply endorsement by the APA.
Does the company have behavioral health providers guiding the development of the AI scribe?
The APA recommends beginning with the company itself and evaluating whether behavioral health expertise meaningfully informs product development, testing, and oversight.
PMHScribe is guided by a Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner with more than 30 years of healthcare experience, including clinical practice, practice management, insurance operations, and Medicare and Medicaid audit oversight.
In addition to internal clinical leadership, PMHScribe has consulted with prescribing psychologists, psychiatrists, licensed clinical professional counselors, and licensed clinical social workers throughout product testing and release. Clinicians using the platform continually provide structured feedback through built-in review tools that directly inform ongoing development.
PMHScribe also consults with experts in culturally competent care to reduce assumptions related to gender identity and minimize bias in clinical documentation.
Is the tool standalone, integrated via API, or bundled within an EHR platform?
PMHScribe is a standalone clinical documentation platform. It can be used through a web browser or via a native iOS app on iPhone or iPad. API integrations and plugins are planned, but are not required for use.
This design supports clinicians who work across multiple systems, use hybrid in-person and telehealth models, or work in settings outside a single outpatient EHR.
Does the tool support ambient listening and dictation?
Yes. PMHScribe supports both ambient listening during live sessions and post-visit dictation or transcript upload. Clinicians choose the workflow that aligns with their consent practices and documentation preferences.
What note templates are available?
PMHScribe supports common behavioral health documentation formats, including SOAP, DAP, and BIRP notes, as well as psychiatry-specific templates.
Are templates customizable?
Yes. Templates can be customized by the clinician using tutorials or with assistance from prompt engineers to match specialty-specific, payer-specific, or personal documentation styles.
Does it work for in-person and virtual visits?
Yes. PMHScribe supports in-person visits and telehealth encounters via a web browser or the iOS mobile app.
Can it be used when multiple parties are part of a clinical appointment?
Yes. The platform differentiates between speakers, allowing accurate documentation of family sessions, collateral visits, and group therapy.
Does the tool perform well across accents, dialects, or speech variation?
PMHScribe has been tested across a wide range of speech patterns and accents to support accurate transcription without favoring a specific regional or cultural speech style.
For sessions conducted in languages other than English, PMHScribe allows transcript uploads in another language for conversion into structured notes. Ambient transcription and translation for non-English languages are not currently supported.
What is the patient experience when an AI scribe is used?
PMHScribe is a provider-facing application. Patients do not interact directly with the software.
If used ambienally during a session, the clinician obtains informed consent. If used after a visit as a dictation or documentation aid, consent considerations are consistent with standard EHR documentation practices and Business Associate Agreements.
Patients may experience indirect benefits such as faster delivery of follow-up instructions, letters of accommodation, out-of-network statements, and post-visit documentation.
Is there additional functionality beyond note generation?
Yes. PMHScribe can infer therapy themes, document interactive complexity, format notes to support medical necessity, generate medication education, assist with lab and medical orders, support medical decision-making documentation, identify psychotherapy add-ons, suggest CPT codes, and draft prior authorizations with citation support.
Is audio recorded, stored, or retrievable?
No. PMHScribe does not create audio recordings that can be retrieved.
PMHScribe uses real-time speech-to-text technology, not audio recording technology. Speech-to-text converts spoken words into text as audio passes through the system. The audio itself is not saved, archived, or accessible after processing.
This distinction is critical. There is no audio file that can be replayed, downloaded, or retrieved later.
How does speech-to-text work in PMHScribe?
PMHScribe uses speech-to-text software designed for real-time transcription. Audio is processed moment-by-moment to generate text tokens as speech occurs. Once transcription is complete within milliseconds, the transient audio signal is discarded.
Speech-to-text systems clean and normalize incoming sound, identify speech patterns, and convert those patterns into text using neural networks trained on diverse speech data. This allows accurate transcription even in real-world environments with background noise or varied speech styles.
Is audio stored temporarily during transcription?
Audio segments are deleted in 10 milliseconds after being converted to text. It is not stored as a retrievable file. There is no audio archive, library, or playback capability within PMHScribe.
Why does this matter for privacy?
Audio recordings pose a higher privacy risk than text because they can contain biometric voice identifiers and contextual information. By using real-time speech-to-text without retaining audio files, PMHScribe reduces data persistence and limits exposure in the event of a security incident.
Is data encrypted in transit and at rest?
Yes. PMHScribe uses 256-bit encryption for all data in transit and at rest and is hosted on HIPAA-secure servers within a hardened cloud environment.
How does PMHScribe address advanced security expectations?
PMHScribe focuses on implementing concrete, operational safeguards rather than marketing certifications. These safeguards include role-based access controls, secure authentication, audit logging, monitoring, incident response procedures, automated logouts, and data minimization practices to limit the retention of sensitive information.
Is the tool HIPAA compliant, and is a Business Associate Agreement required?
Yes. PMHScribe attests to HIPAA compliance and enters into a Business Associate Agreement.
Is data de-identified during transcription?
Yes. Transcripts are scrubbed of identifying information before being processed into structured clinical notes. Clinicians then assign final identifiers manually, maintaining separation between raw transcript data and the clinical record.
Are transcripts retained, and who controls retention?
Transcripts are not part of the EHR. They are stored within PMHScribe for clinician review only. Users have full control over transcript retention and deletion.
Does the company use session data to train AI models?
No. Session data is not automatically used to train proprietary language models. Providers must actively submit feedback to request an assessment of output quality.
Does the company sell data or use it for marketing?
No. PMHScribe does not sell de-identified clinical data and does not use patient or session data for marketing. Access requires NPI validation to restrict use to licensed clinicians. Sales and marketing teams receive HIPAA and Responsible AI training.
Does the company provide guidance on state-specific consent requirements?
Yes. PMHScribe provides educational resources on state-specific AI and recording consent requirements, including those in Illinois. NPI validation is required to ensure appropriate provider use and compliance with licensure requirements.
Evaluating an AI scribe requires more than feature lists. It requires transparency, clinical oversight, privacy protection, and alignment with professional guidance.
PMHScribe was built specifically for behavioral health clinicians who want flexible workflows, accurate documentation, and strong privacy controls without sacrificing efficiency. If you are exploring AI scribes and want a tool designed for mental health care, you can learn more or request a demo at https://www.pmhscribe.com.
“The American Psychological Association does not endorse, certify, approve, or grade AI scribes. Its guidance is intended to support clinician judgment, ethical practice, and compliance with applicable laws.”
Disclaimer: This article is an independent educational summary written by PMHScribe based on publicly available APA guidance. It has not been reviewed, approved, or evaluated by the American Psychological Association, and nothing in this article should be interpreted as an APA endorsement, certification, approval, grading, or assessment of PMHScribe or any other AI scribe. This content is also not connected to any paid listing, directory placement, or fee-based marketing program.
This checklist is an independent educational resource inspired by APA guidance and is not reviewed or endorsed by the American Psychological Association.